Thursday, November 2, 2017

Endoscopy or the Mirror Exam: Guideline Adaptation in Oncology Care in Botswana




Shekinah Nefreteri Elmore, MD, MPH
Resident, Harvard Radiation Oncology Program
PGY3

I was thrilled to be back in Botswana in the oncology department at the Princess Marina Hospital, the large Ministry of Health facility in the Gaborone. I had traveled there once before during my intern year for a month long rotation project. While I already came to the experience with more than a year at an oncology facility in Rwanda, I hadn’t yet begun my radiation oncology residency, and thus had had little formal oncology instruction. Coming back with nearly a year behind me did wonders, both for how helpful I was able to be to the clinical oncologists in their consultations, but also how I saw the system and my project. Tasked with helping to think through how complex, international cancer care guidelines could be simplified to meet the needs of oncologists and their patients in Botswana was both more enriching and more nuanced after a year in my training program.



Sitting with one of the clinical officers in the outpatient oncology clinic, we met a lovely, older patient with a head and neck cancer. He was my first such patient, as my rotation in this specific anatomic site would take place in the next academic year. But, with all of the teaching conferences and articles that we benefit from, I knew some basics and could help and follow along with the more experienced doctor.

We proceed to a physical exam after getting a close history, feeling lymph nodes in the neck carefully and looking at the dusky, white, plump tonsil that harbored the cancer with the help of a tongue depressor and pen light. Though I’d never done it or seen it, I knew that the next step was the completely but baroquely named nasopharyngolargyngoscopy, or passing a thin, fiberoptic camera scope through the patient’s nostril and down to the precipice above their vocal chords. This would allow us to see what path of local travel the cancer had taken and hone down on our treatment recommendations. Asking the doctor if the scope would be done, she said that it had been broken for some time.

Guidelines are a complicated series of hopes and certainties, in this sense. While it is fine and likely appropriate to recommend an endoscopy for staging in a head and neck guideline in Botswana, because technically there is a scope unlike in some more resource-constrained settings, recommending this as the only means of staging would be an unfortunate omission of other possibilities. The more viable options and the more creativity we can bring to this process, the better.

For example, while endoscopy has become a mainstream practice, this is very recent. Previously, a “mirror exam” or use of a simple dental mirror, light source, and head mirror provided physicians with a comparable view of the same terrain. Both options should be included in such guidelines. And, further, an assessment of how often one or the other is performed could be captured over time to document the true availability of advanced technologies such as endoscopy and to trouble shoot their breakdowns. It would have been easy to write a guideline that included endoscopy as the only option, simple because no time on site, no time in clinic with the actual care providers had taught me any better.

My time in Botswana reinforced the lesson of global health and implementation that I learn again and again: we must always work in partnership to know what is realistic while still championing what is ideal.

2 comments:

  1. Hello everyone i want to thank herbal doctor razor for what he did in my life,i was diagnosed of herpes virus 3 years ago and ever since then i have been battling with this deadly virus,i have tried countless medical treatment but all to no avail,i got to know that this medical drugs never really cures this disease but rather it makes the disease stay dormant in the body and the medical drugs has been causing me severe damages other than helping me out,being frustrated with the medical treatment i decided against taking the medical treatment and opted for African herbs because i have seen the great importance of herbs at a very tender age,i began searching different forums for a true healer of this infection it was during this period of time i came across a testimony on how herbalist Razor has been saving lives with his herbal medicine ,i decided to contact him with the hope of getting my redemption,i contacted him with the details provided by the testifier DONNA BECKY,and we spoke,he told me not to worry after i have explained everything to him and he promised to help me get rid of the deadly infection and he told me what i needed to do which i did and 4 days after contacting him i received a parcel from the UPS delivery service and it was from this great herbal doctor RAZOR,i told him i received the parcel he sent to me,so he later guided me on how i was to take the herbal medicine and after 21 days of taking his herbs i began noticing some changes in my health i explained to him and he told me to go for a medical test and to my greatest surprise the same medical doctor who broke the sad news to me 3 years ago told me that it was a miracle how my STATUS has changed from positive to negativity.i was overwhelmed with joy,i made him a promise if he was able to cure me that i will make sure the world gets to know of his work.thank you so much sir.you can contact him if you are having similar problem via his clinic email drrazorherbalhome@gmail.com Whatsapp/Call him on +2349065420442

    ReplyDelete
  2. God bless Dr. USELU for his marvelous work in my life, I was diagnosed of HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS since 2018 and I was taking my medications, I wasn't satisfied i needed to get the HERPES out of my system, I searched about some possible cure for HERPES i saw a comment about Dr. USELU , how he cured HERPES with his herbal medicine, I contacted him and he guided me. I asked for solutions, he started the remedy for my health, he sent me the medicine within 3 days. I took the medicine as prescribed by him and 2weeks later  i was cured from HERPES contact him via email (dr.uselucaregiver@gmail.com) once again thanks to you Dr. USELU cure the flowing virus, contact his email or add him on whatsapp (+2349019328641) cancer cure
    diabetes cure
    ringing ear
    herpes cure
    warts cure
    HPV cure
    HIV cure
    get your ex back
    pregnancy herbal medicine
    Hepatitis     

    ReplyDelete