Wednesday, March 30, 2016

Improving Access to and Safety of Anesthetic Care in Rwanda through Education Part 2:

Elliott Woodward, MD
Resident in Anesthesia, BWH
PGY 4


Much progress had already been made in terms of transferring the role of primary educator for the Foundation and core curriculum from visitors to the local Rwandans by the time I arrived in Rwanda.  So, my role during these sessions as a visitor assisting CASIEF was to work alongside local anesthesia attendings to support senior resident led teaching.  The educational focus during the month of my visit was on neurology and perioperative management of patients with neuropathology and/or those requiring neurosurgery. 

 Each week, a senior resident was assigned the role of teacher.  This resident was provided with a list of the subjects to be covered during their week approximately one month in advance as well as instructions to provide an interactive lecture environment for the rest of their group.  From the time the assignment was made until the day that the teaching was provided, I worked with the resident teacher to help them prepare their presentation, key readings, and questions related to their topic which were to be distributed to the rest of the residents a week before the lecture.  

On Mondays, I sat in on the lectures, helped to steer the discussions, provided guidance for the presenters when needed, and answered any questions that arose that the student teacher was unable to answer.

Some Rwandan residents excelled in the role of educator while others required much more support.  Regardless, I can honestly say that I learned as much as I taught in this role over the course of the month.  I spent many nights during my time in Rwanda pouring through “Big Miller”, (a comprehensive anesthesia text authored by Ronald Miller referred to as Big Miller for a very good reason….) just to be sure that I could answer any tough questions that might arise.  Still I found myself challenged and often in the role of the student when faced with the day-to-day of Rwandan practice.  For example, while it is relatively straight forward to teach the effect that various anesthetics have on intracranial pressure (ICP) and to discuss the approach used in our hospitals at home when managing patients with with elevated ICP,I found this discussion much more complex when reflecting on management of the same patients in Rwanda.  

Many of the hospitals in Rwanda either a) don’t have access to the medications that we would normally use for these cases or b) don’t have easy access to treat the known side effects (such as hypotension) related their use.  This led to some interesting discussions delving into the complexities of polypharmacy in order to balance the desired and undesired effects of the available medications.  I walked away from these talks with some reading to do after my Rwandan counterparts referenced a number of papers on the subject that I was not familiar with.  I reviewed the literature and later, while trying to relay what I had learned, I found myself in some of the most rewarding and perhaps most educational interactions that I had in the whole month.  While these discussions were meant to relate back to our original topic of neuroanesthesia, I found that the most valuable teaching points that came out of these were instead related to the critical appraisal of medical literature.  

Though unfortunately there was not enough time formally dedicated to this topic in the current curriculum, it was something that the residents asked me to revisit with them multiple times over the month during downtime in the operating rooms.  Ultimately I think that a number of them left these interactions with a more structured approach to the assessment of the quality of evidence presented in medical literature and a better understanding of how to apply it to their setting.  This is a skill that I hope will stick with them as they embark on the rest of their adventure as practitioners and, hopefully, lifelong learners.

Though our role as “classroom based educators” was primarily a supportive one as previously described, we were occasionally asked to give lectures ourselves.  While challenging and a learning process for me in a different way, this ultimately proved to be equally rewarding.  One such lecture was on the topic of fluid management and was one that I am fairly certain will result in a very real change in practice by the residents which I hope will trickle down to the anesthesia techs that work closely with them.  Prior to the lecture, the residents seemed to be choosing fluids for patients in the operating rooms and ICUs on a whim.  For example, while working with a resident in the ICU one day, I noticed a patient who was in the process of recovery from septic shock who had a significant hyperchloremic nonanion gap metabolic acidosis after resuscitation with multiple liters of normal saline. 

  This complication is a well recognized side effect of resuscitation with large volumes of this fluid, yet this patient was still receiving it.  When discussing the case with the resident, it became clear that their choice of fluids (colloid vs crystalloid as well as crystalloid vs crystalloid) was very practitioner dependent and almost exclusively at random.  After an hour-long lecture to the entire group of residents the following week, they reported a significant improvement in their understanding of fluid therapy and were able to clearly articulate and defend their reasoning behind choosing certain fluids when quizzed after the lecture and when discussing patient care in the operating rooms and ICUs later during my trip.

Clinical teaching was another important part of my duties which took up much of my time Tuesday through Thursday each week. The residency program sent residents to four main teaching hospitals, three of which are in the capital city of Kigali with the fourth located in Huye in the South of Rwanda.  I spent my first few weeks of the trip in Kigali and one week primarily teaching in Huye.  While in Kigali, Tuesdays and Fridays were spent at University Central Hospital of Kigali (CHUK), Wednesdays at Rwandan Military Hospital (RMH) and Thursdays at King Faisal Hospital (KFH) providing intraoperative and ICU-based teaching.  With only 11 clinically active anesthesiologists in the entire country, it was the norm to have entire hospitals including the ICU, labor and delivery, and the operating rooms with up to six ORs running covered by a single anesthesiologist. 

  While cases that were expected to be particularly challenging were identified ahead of time and discussed each morning with the anesthesiologist on duty, techs were responsible for providing the majority of anesthetics and, in the absence of visitors from CASIEF and HRH, for much of the early hands on intraoperative resident education.  While it is absolutely essential to again recognize the important role that these techs play in the Rwandan health system, their ability to problem solve issues that deviated from the norm was obvious and residents were clearly very happy to have myself and Dr. Stewart Chritton around to provide teaching and guidance with respect to the intraoperative and ICU based care of their patients.  While I would like to believe that some of that teaching will benefit future patients by shaping their clinical practice for the better, I can say with relative certainty that we were able to improve the care that was provided to some of the patients that were hospitalized during our time there. 
           
  Perhaps the most obvious example of our influence on clinical care relates to the use of regional anesthesia.  Despite the fact that many patients that present to the ORs in Rwanda are excellent candidates for regional anesthesia, either as their primary anesthetic or to help improve post operative pain control and therefore perioperative outcome, use has historically been limited due to the fact that none of the current Rwandan anesthesia attendings are trained in these techniques.  A visiting anesthesiologist from Canada working with HRH who completed a regional anesthesia fellowship set out to change this during his four months in Rwanda.  

He developed a regional anesthesia education curriculum including didactic lectures and hands-on simulation in the simulation lab.  He also worked with the local surgeons and other visitors to help create an environment that was open and appropriately supportive of efforts to promote regional anesthesia.  His time in Rwanda overlapped with ours and we found ourselves intimately involved in almost every aspect of his efforts including supervision of blocks in the OR.  While the blocks that we supervised certainly helped the patients that they were used on, my hope is that the education that we helped to provide in and out of the ORs will serve as early steps toward the development of a robust regional program that will help patients for years to come.
            
Overall, I had an absolutely amazing experience in Rwanda.  The people were welcoming, the country was beautiful, and the resilience of those in the medical field was inspiring. On a personal level, I learned more than I could have hoped about being an educator during only a very short time.  Most importantly, however, I hope that, small as it may be, Dr. Critton and I were able to make a lasting contribution to the efforts to improve access to and the quality of anesthetic care in this amazing country.


Improving Access to and Safety of Anesthetic Care in Rwanda through Education Part 1

Elliott Woodward, MD
Resident in Anesthesia, BWH
PGY 4


I firmly believe that one of the most important factors in determining the efficacy of a medical trip abroad is how much one understands the history of the place being visited and the cultural context of the care that is already being delivered there.  With that that in mind, I spent what little free time I had in the weeks leading up to my trip to Rwanda learning everything that I could about the country.  I was lucky enough to be accompanied on this adventure by a BWH anesthesia attending named Stewart Chritton who had spent a year living and working as an anesthesiologist in the capital city of Kigali two years prior to our trip. 

Through discussions with Stewart, informational material from the Canadian Anesthesiologist’s Society International Education Foundation or CASIEF (the organization that I would be working under during my time in Rwanda), books such as “Land of 1000 Hills”, and published materials on the Rwandan anesthesia residency, I learned what I could before leaving.  Shortly after arriving in Rwanda, I supplemented this knowledge through an early visit to the Genocide War Memorial in Kigali and discussions with locals employed by CASIEF.  In this way, I began to build a more nuanced picture of Rwanda, its history, and the task that lay ahead of me as a visiting educator for their anesthesia residency.

Rwanda is a small country in the Great Lakes region of Africa with a population of ~11.8 million inhabitants.  It is difficult to understand much about this country, including the current state of anesthetic practice, without referencing its tumultuous past and the genocide that took place within its boarders in April of 1994.  The events leading up to the genocide are complex, with their origins tracing back to as early as the 1880s at which time the country was first colonized by Europeans.  Under German and then Belgian rule, the native population was divided into what would later be classified by many as ethnic groupings based largely upon socioeconomic status (how many cows someone owned) and physical characteristics such as height.  

Over the subsequent decades, tensions between two of the major groups that were created (the Tutsi and Hutu) increased as foreign influence favored one group over the other in an effort to maintain control over the country.  Ultimately, after the nation gained independence from Belgium, the Hutu violently revolted against the minority Tutsi population who had previously wielded much of the power in the country and had actively suppressed the Hutu.  This resulted in the expulsion of more than 100,000 Tutsi to the neighboring territories now known as the Congo, Uganda, Burundi and Tanzania.  

The majority of these displaced individuals remained refugees for years as conflict continued between the ruling Hutu in Rwanda and military forces primarily composed of the expelled Tutsi and their families.   Refugee forces and their supporters joined to create a group known as the Rwandan Patriotic Front or RPF which was ultimately led by a man named general Kagame.  This group fought ongoing discrimination and violence against the Tutsi that remained in Rwanda and for the opportunity for those that were displaced to return to their home country.  Conflict between these groups culminated in the genocide of 1994 when a government-led extremist group called for the death of all Tutsi and Tutsi-supporting Hutu that remained in the country.  Approximately 500,000 – 1,000,000 million men, women, and children were killed in a matter of 100 days before the massacre was finally put to an end in July 1994 by the advancing RPF.
          
  The country was torn apart by the genocide and it took some time before it could begin to rebuild and provide services such as medical care.  In fact, in the years immediately after the genocide, there was only one anesthesiologist for the entire country.  Out of necessity, individuals that are now known as anesthesia technicians stepped up to meet the anesthetic needs of the people.  While many early practitioners learned experientially, the field ultimately evolved to its current state, requiring three years of specialty training after high school in order to qualify to practice.  While this group has provided an indispensable service to Rwanda since its inception and still provides the majority of anesthetics in the country, the limitations associated with the brevity of their training remain clear.  In fact, after arriving, I was told of two completely avoidable intraoperative deaths that occurred shortly before we started because a technician didn’t fully understand the risks associated with provision of anesthesia for their patient.
     

       Rwanda recognized long ago the need to increase the number of practicing anesthesiologists in the country in order to keep patients safe during the perioperative period.  Efforts to boost numbers through sending physicians abroad for training were complicated by poor rates of repatriation.  With this in mind, the Rwandan government approached the Canadian government and ask for help creating a Rwandan-based training program, hoping that graduates from this program would be more likely to stay and practice in Rwanda than their foreign-trained counterparts.  The Canadian government agreed and, with the joint support of the American Board of Anesthesiology (ABA), CASIEF helped to establish a Rwandan anesthesia residency which opened its doors in 2006. 

It was with significant input from North American sources that a curriculum was developed for the anesthesia residency in Rwanda, a curriculum initially taught primarily by foreign physicians.  From the beginning, however, the ultimate goal of CASIEF has been to create a system that is capable of training residents in Rwanda without outside support. 

  To this end, CASIEF paired visiting physicians with local providers and, over the years, there has been a transition whereby visitors have moved away from the role of primary educator to one where they supervise/support teaching by local doctors.  This tactic has also been adopted by Rwandan Human Resources for Health (HRH), another organization that was established in order to “lay down the blueprint for guaranteeing long term equitable access to high-quality medical care and education” and has been helping CASIEF to educate the Rwandan residents over the past few years.  (As an aside, I am proud to say that the Anesthesia Department at Brigham and Women’s Hospital has played an important role in many of the successes that these organizations have achieved as multiple resident and attending volunteers have served as volunteers in Rwanda through HRH and CASIEF over the years.)

Currently, the residency is structured so that each Monday is an “academic day,” where residents are entirely free from clinical duties with their day instead filled with didactic lectures, case reports, and simulation-based training.  In terms of didactic education on Mondays, visitors working with HRH are responsible for what has ultimately been labeled “foundations,” a year-long introduction to anesthesia for first-year residents which covers the breadth of intraoperative anesthesia practice through what is largely a systems-based approach. CASIEF visitors such as myself on the other hand are responsible for facilitating a similar course for the senior residents called “core curriculum”.  With this structure, residents cover material multiple times over the course of their residency, with the intent that the depth and sophistication of their grasp of the material increases each time that a subject is revisited.


With the above in mind, I gathered my things to head to the hospital on the first Monday after my arrival.  As I walked through the crowded streets leading to work, I remained eager to determine the best way to contribute during my short time in Rwanda, and to see what things I too could learn about the practice of anesthesia from this group of people whose perspective on medical care was inevitably so much different than my own. 



Emergency Medicine Bedside Ultrasound Training CHUK hospital in Kigali, Rwanda



Kristin Dwyer, MD, MPH
Fellow in Emergency Ultrasound, BWH
PGY 6


 I am currently in Rwanda, where I have returned to work in the University Central Hospital of Kigali (CHUK) hospital. It is a public hospital in Kigali, and is an academic referral and teaching center. There are many other hospitals in town, including King Faisal (a more modern private hospital) and the military hospital.



CHUK Hospital, Front Entrance. Kigali, Rwanda

Emergency medicine (EM) is a new specialty here, and many general practitioners (GPs) continue to staff the emergency room due to inadequate number of fully trained EM specialists. However, some GPs, who have been practicing clinically for many years, have now entered the emergency medicine residency alongside new graduates.

I am working in the emergency department (ED), running the residency ultrasound rotation. So far, I have had two residents per day on the rotation. They each rotate for one month through ultrasound training. We join rounds in the morning, and identify patients who may benefit clinically from a bedside ultrasound.  We spend 8 hours a day ultrasounding patients in the emergency department and communicating all our findings through the patient chart, and directly to the clinical team.  We are fortunate in that our machines are functioning well, and we have adequate supplies of ultrasound gel. 


This week we had a woman who had been waiting for three days for a cat scan of her abdomen to look for appendicitis.  Cat scans are not performed here until families can pay upfront for the test, and even then it is not uncommon for it to take days to occur.  We were able to locate her appendix on bedside ultrasound and diagnose her with appendicitis at no cost. 

Bedside Ultrasound Teaching with Residents: CHUK
In addition, we have been able to diagnose many patients with tuberculosis using the FASH exam, and finding para-aortic lymph nodes in combination with micro-abscesses in the spleen and/or liver. 

We have also been working on ultrasound guided procedural skills, in particular peripheral ultrasound venous access. This week we came in and a patient with DKA, who was acidemic, hypokalemic and very ill appearing, had waited overnight all night with no interventions, treatments or medication because the overnight team had been unable to gain peripheral access. The residents were able to use bedside ultrasound to obtain a peripheral IV line and the patient ended up doing very well, and was discharged home 2 days later.

While there have been some IRB delays with the research project I am planning to help out with here, I have been able to do some advanced lung ultrasound training for those individuals who will be working on the project in preparation of IRB approval.


I look forward to the second half of my rotation where I will continue to do ultrasound training with a new group of residents, and I will be giving some lectures during department conference day. 



Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Hand and Burn Surgery in Kigali, Rwanda Week 1


Lydia Helliwell, MD
Resident in Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery, BWH
PGY 6

I have traveled to Kigali, Rwanda with two of my colleagues, Dr. Simon Talbot and Sarah Kinsley, Physician Assistant, both part of the Plastic Surgery Department at Brigham and Women’s Hospital. Dr. Talbot is fellowship trained in hand surgery and I will be completing my fellowship this upcoming year. We learned through contacts in Kiagli that a total of two plastic surgeons worked in the entirely of Rwanda, a country of nearly 12 million people. For comparison, we have 15 plastic surgeons at Brigham and Women’s alone. Thus, tough reconstructive problems, and specifically tough hand and burn reconstructive cases, can often go untreated. We partnered with our colleagues at the University Teaching Hospital of Kigali (aka. CHUK), to help provide hand surgery teaching to attendings, residents and students over a two-week period.
Outside view of CHUK

We arrived in Kigali late Sunday evening and the following morning a Ministry of Health truck picked us up from the hotel and drove us the 30 minutes across Kigali to CHUK. There we met with Dr. Fausten, the only plastic surgeon serving the public hospital. We started the day with a 2-hour clinic, where patients from the local area with various hand problems were brought in to meet us. We saw approximately 20 patients in that 2 hour period, almost all with operative hand problems spanning both congenital and post-traumatic issues, including pre- and post-axial polydactyl, complex burn injuries, encondromas, syndactyly, fractures, tumors and Volkman’s contractures. We booked 14 surgeries for the next 3 days, in conjunction with Dr. Fausten, as well as the general surgery residents and students.

Operating in the CHUK O.R. with one of the general surgery residents
After clinic we toured the surgical wards and the burn unit. The units were large rooms containing several beds where patients were being attended to by medical students, nurses, residents and their families. We saw a variety of complex injuries in the surgical ward and a number of tough pediatric burn cases in the burn unit. Although their units lacked most of the modern conveniences we enjoy, the students, residents, nurses and families worked incredibly hard to provide the best care to their patients without the resources we have at our disposal. It certainly made me appreciate the resources available in our Boston hospitals, which can be easy to take for granted.

View down the CHUK operating room hallway
We arrived early the next morning for our first full day of operating. The operating rooms were located in a large building dating from the 1950’s. Although it was old and lacked many of the modern machines and technology that our own operating rooms contain, I was impressed by the complexity of the cases going on around us. CHUK is a public hospital, which is the referral hospital for approximately two-thirds of Rwanda, so the pathology and complexity they see is impressive. However, performing hand surgery and complex reconstructive surgery is difficult in this environment for several reasons. One, they lack the tools needed for hand surgery, including everything from sharp surgical instruments to fine sutures to microscopes. Additionally, with only two plastic surgeons, there are few people trained to take care of these problems, and hand and and burn injuries are incredibly common here, especially in a population that has many people performing manual labor and working with fire.

That first day we performed five procedures in conjunction with the local team, and 9 more over the following two days. The days were long (and hot!), but it was incredibly rewarding to provide care to patients that they might not otherwise receive and to work with the local physicians to teach them techniques to deal with problems they see commonly. Next week we will continue to operate with plans to undertake several burn reconstructive procedures for patients who have been in the burn unit for several days to weeks. We will also continue to work with students and residents, to both help start their training in plastic and hand surgery, and hopefully inspire them to potentially pursue further training.



Monday, March 21, 2016

Clinical Experience at the University College Hospital (UCH)


Oluwatosin( Tosin) Onibokun, MD
Resident in OB/GYN, BWH/MGH Combined Residency Program
PGY 3

While at the University College Hospital (UCH), I had a chance to observe clinical work at the family planning clinic.
Hallway at the Family planning clinic at the
University College Hospital (UCH)

I was impressed by the major role the nurses played in the counseling and  provision of contraception to women. Contrary to the norm in the United States, insertions of reversible long acting contraception were managed by the nurses at the family planning clinic (including placement and removal of contraceptive implants and intrauterine devices) with doctors available for back up as needed (which appeared to rarely happen).I think the training and empowerment of nurses in this area is very laudable and the right step towards expanding 

Posters in family planning clinic promoting promoting
contraception use as a form of child spacing



















Of note, all reversible long-acting contraception ( IUDs and implants) provided at the family planning clinic at UCH are fully funded by the Nigerian Urban Reproductive Health Initiative (NURHI), which is a project funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation with the goal to eliminate the supply and demand barriers to contraceptive use in Nigeria, a very laudable and inspiring goal. The patients only pay a nominal fee to pay for the cost of syringes, needles and local anesthesia.  This highlights to me the role of philanthropy in making an immense significant impact in the lives of people and nations.

I think the available funding explains why I saw more implantable contraception devices inserted into patients than I initially expected given their relatively high cost in the United States. 


On the other hand, it was also interesting to note that the public awareness campaigns regarding contraception (with the exception of condoms) is skewed towards helping married women ensure adequate spacing between children and less as a way to prevent unwanted pregnancies in young unmarried women who are sexually active. This skew can be noted in the pictures that advertise contraception use. However,  I think it is important to modify this rhetoric so that young women, married or not and parous or not, can have equitable access to effective contraception.

In summary, it was a great learning experience to observe the efforts at improving access to contraception in a Nigerian setting, a cause I hope to continue to be involved in as an OB/GYN.



Oluwatosin( Tosin) Onibokun,
OB/GYN Resident PGY 3
BWH/MGH Combine Residency Program







Research at the University College Hospital (UCH)

Oluwatosin( Tosin) Onibokun, MD
Resident in OB/GYN BWH/MGH Combined Residency Program
PGY 3



  
With one of the nurses on
 the labor and delivery ward
 
Being born and raised in Nigeria till the age of 17, going back for my research elective during my 3rd year as an OB/GYN resident was in line with part of my future goals to be involved and contribute in a positive way to the health care system in sub Saharan Africa.  I chose to focus on studying the attitudes, knowledge and practice of health care providers towards providing reversible long -acting contraception- particularly intrauterine contraception devices (IUDs), to adolescents, young and unmarried women in one of the major teaching hospitals in Nigeria.

As an OB/GYN resident, I realize how challenging it can be to provide adequate contraception to women both in developed and developing countries. Nonetheless, I believe providing adequate contraception for women is a way to empower women to achieve their economic, educational, social and personal goals and potential, therefore this was a topic I was excited to explore within the Nigerian context. 

With two of the senior residents at the morning review 

On commencing my research experience at the University College Hospital( UCH), Ibadan,  I was overwhelmed by how receptive and welcoming the study participants – OB/GYN residents, nurses and consultants (attendings) were.  I was not sure of the kind of reception I would receive exploring a culturally and socially sensitive topic like providing contraception to sexually active teenagers in a relatively conservative culture like the Nigerian culture. However, my participants were very open and engaged with the study.  

Without any proding whatsoever on my part, many of them discussed their own personal opinions with me about the use of reversible long acting contraception like (IUDs) in young women as they filled out the anonymous and confidential questionnaires. One of them shared an anecdote of a teenage woman that was a post partum patient in her ward and how her pregnancy may have been prevented with adequate contraception while another expressed concern about how the use of long-acting contraception could promote promiscuity among teenagers. Listening to the lively discussions that usually ensued among the participants served as encouragement to me on how important this topic is. 


Those discussions also further confirmed to me that, although the topic of contraception for young women is usually  “ the elephant in the room”, people are potentially open to a dialogue about it - dialogues that I think need to take place in order to improve access to effective contraception for young women.






































Reflection  #2

Clinical experience at the University College Hospital (UCH):




Hall- way at the Family planning clinic at the University College Hospital
( UCH)

While at the University College Hospital (UCH), I had a chance to observe clinical work at the family planning clinic.
I was impressed by the major role the nurses played in the counseling and  provision of contraception to women. Contrary to the norm in the United States, insertions of reversible long acting contraception were managed by the nurses at the family planning clinic (including placement and removal of contraceptive implants and intrauterine devices) with doctors available for back up as needed (which appeared to rarely happen).I think the training and empowerment of nurses in this area is very laudable and the right step towards expanding adequate contraception.
Of note, all reversible long-acting contraception ( IUDs and implants) provided at the family planning clinic at UCH are fully funded by the Nigerian Urban Reproductive Health Initiative (NURHI), which is a project funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation with the goal to eliminate the supply and demand barriers to contraceptive use in Nigeria, a very laudable and inspiring goal. The patients only pay a nominal fee to pay for the cost of syringes, needles and local anesthesia.  This highlights to me the role of philanthropy in making an immense significant impact in the lives of people and nations.
I think the available funding explains why I saw more implantable contraception devices inserted into patients than I initially expected given their relatively high cost in the United States.



        


Posters in family planning clinic promoting contraception use as a form of child spacing


On the other hand, it was also interesting to note that the public awareness campaigns regarding contraception (with the exception of condoms) is skewed towards helping married women ensure adequate spacing between children and less as a way to prevent unwanted pregnancies in young unmarried women who are sexually active. This skew can be noted in the pictures that advertise contraception use. However,  I think it is important to modify this rhetoric so that young women, married or not and parous or not, can have equitable access to effective contraception.

In summary, it was a great learning experience to observe the efforts at improving access to contraception in a Nigerian setting, a cause I hope to continue to be involved in as an OB/GYN.



Oluwatosin( Tosin) Onibokun,
OB/GYN Resident PGY 3
BWH/MGH Combine Residency Program






Thursday, March 17, 2016

Social History

Jessica Hoy, MD
Resident in Internal Medicine, BWH
PGY 2


Recently in clinic at the Northern Navajo Medical Center in Shiprock, New Mexico, I saw a lovely 77 year old woman who was doing quite well. She had occasional urinary tract infections but she dealt with these at home and rarely came to clinic. A few months before I met her, she had been admitted with a kidney infection. 

As we discussed her UTIs, I suggested she try to come into clinic when she is feeling unwell so we could catch any infections before they got out of control. She smiled patiently at me and explained that her husband and daughter are disabled and none of them can drive: “So when I get sick, I walk to the highway and hitchhike to the doctor,” she said, coyly holding out her thumb.  It was hard to picture this little grandmother standing along the side of the highway awaiting a ride when her illness finally pushed her to seek medical care. But it was important for me to pay attention: this patient was teaching me a lesson about the social history of our patients at NNMC.

Like most medical practices, the lives of patients at NNMC vary broadly.  Some patients live several hours away, some live in cities, some live on the reservation.  But NNMC seems to have a special focus on understanding the social circumstances of the most marginalized and disadvantaged patients in the Navajo community.  For example, one doctor explained to me,  “sometimes we need to do things differently here; we may admit a little old lady with viral gastroenteritis so she doesn’t break a hip when she goes out to use her outhouse.”  Another time, as I was leaving the room of a patient that I was admitting, a nurse came in behind me and asked her own social history: “Do you have electricity in the home? Do you have heat? Do you have hot water?”  
Shiprock High School Girl's Basketball Game

It would be clichéd and naïve to say that this level of poverty on the reservation stunned me.   While my careful but common questions about my patients’ social history (eg. alcohol, tobacco and drug use) are important, they don’t begin to scratch the surface of the social circumstance of some of these patients.   

Getting to know the community has been one of the greatest privileges of being in Shiprock. From spending time with patients’ families to attending a high school basketball game, I have gotten a small glimpse of a world that is very different than the world of my patients in Boston. 

  This opportunity, to know a community deeper  and through fresh eyes, is why I wanted to come to Shiprock and what I will continue to carry with me as I return to Boston and the familiar community awaiting me there.



Friday, March 11, 2016

Passing the Baton

Tony Joseph, MD
Fellow in Emergency Medicine, PHS
PGY 3

            At the end our 4 weeks we have successfully trained severe members of the surgical house staff in point of care ultrasound. These guys and girls see an incredible high volume of trauma and now have proven that they have the skills to make the right calls for the right patients. Several of our midwives have even started running their own course for their peers on using ultrasound in all trimesters of pregnancy. We hope that this group will take their new skills and run with it as they advance in their medical training.
            
We were able to run a trauma course with a modified ATLS approach to trauma and along with that incorporate the extended focused assessment with sonography in trauma (E-FAST) exam. 

Fortunately most of the surgical residents were already up to speed on their ultrasound skills having spend the last 4 weeks with us that they would not spend the course focusing on chest tubes and intubation.  


   
There were times when we ran out of power for the machine, or gel to use as a medium to use between the patient and the ultrasound probe/transducer. For a normal guy like me this would have put an end to the day, but as seen in the photo below, the surgical residents here are very creative in using their resources.

This chest tube drain is the simplest water seal I have ever seen and is also incredibly effective.
Excited to see how far our trainees turned  instructors take their new skills when we come back for our next visit.
             












Total Immersion in Ultrasound

Tony Joseph, MD
Resident in Emergency Medicine at PHS
PGY 3



Just started off our first week at Mbarara Regional Referral Hospital (MRRH) in Southwestern Uganda! Led by PURE co-founder, Dr. Trish Henwood, this team welcomes back Drs. Katie O’Brien (Kaiser Sacramento), Dave Mackenzie (Maine Med) & Newman (Penn) and brought in some new crew members: Dr. Elizabeth Hall (Penn), Simone Schriger, and me – Tony Joseph from Brigham/Mass General.

We hit the ground running with a full week of ultrasound training sessions for the OB midwives, house staff interns/residents, and surgical staff. Within a single day, physician trainees went from not knowing where the power button on the machine was to identifying subtle fluid stripes in Morison’s pouch and distinguishing free fluid fake outs in the pelvis from real pathology. Seminal vesicles will fool them no more!

Dr. Peter (surgical resident) was able to quickly utilize the knowledge and skills he gained on a Friday after he found himself on call in Accidents & Emergency on Sunday. 

A trauma patient presented with abdominal pain after a motorcycle crash, the FAST was positive for free fluid in the abdomen concerning for hemorrhage. The patient was taking to the operation theatre immediately and found to have a grade IV splenic laceration. Point-of-care ultrasound making a difference off the bat!

Many of the intern trainees quickly realized the power of ultrasound and started asking about other applications such as vascular access and hydronephrosis. With this level of interest, we expect their bedside scanning skills to take off quickly.

Meanwhile, the OB midwives and attendings who had received training on our last visit, showcased their wonderful OB ultrasound skills that they have been using all year long! Several 2nd & 3rd trimester pregnant patients from clinic volunteered to be scanned and the local staff correctly made biometry measurements to date the pregnancies.

We are also preparing for a trauma course in early February along with coordinating trauma surgeon, Dr. Deepika Nehra. Now that the physicians are getting the FAST exam down, they just have to learn A through E. 

More to come on that later… 

Back to scanning!

















































Monday, March 7, 2016

Reflection at Shiprock


Jessica Hoy, MD
Resident in Medicine at BWH
PGY 2

As I drove from the airport several hours along a long dark road to the Indian Health Services in Shiprock, New Mexico, I found my mind wandering to the last leap of faith I took nine years before.  I was a new college graduate. Friends were starting their consulting or investment jobs or graduate school pursuits.  I was traveling in the front seat of an Egypt Airways truck without a seat belt in the early hours of morning to the Nairobi Airport for my puddle-jumper to Kisumu, then on to a small town in Western Kenya where I was about to spend a year.  I had the great fortune of winning a grant during college for a year of purposeful travel, where I was to discover myself and find my way after years of clear direction and advancement during boarding school and college.  I found my first weeks in my small village to be painfully chaotic; for the first time in my life I lacked a sense of purpose or a set of skills to develop.  I spent my time working at a local health center.  Skill-less in the medical realm, I was an extra pair of hands in the small cinder block building that served as an outpost of medical care for the community of mud huts that sprawled through the dusty red hills under a never ending sky. 

Sunset from the Hospital
I felt a similar fear of the unknown as my rental car sped towards Shiprock along the dark flat landscape that pulsed beyond my high beams.  I was leaving the comfort and certainty of residency, of early rising and the rhythm of rounding, of familiar faces of attendings and common concerns of patients for a part of the country and a patient population to which I had no knowledge or connections.  The timing was not a mistake.  I was leaving exactly in the middle of residency, with 18 months behind and 18 months ahead, just as it was becoming acceptable for attendings to ask where I would end up next year, guessing that I, as a passionate defender of primary care, would be seeking a career rather than a fellowship.  But as that time approaches, I have been feeling unease as I picture myself in my mentors’ shoes.  Despite so many people that I love and admire at the Brigham, I haven’t been certain about where I fit and where I will fit when the thrilling adventure of residency ends and everyone moves on in their set path.  So here I am at the Indian Health Services. The circumstances are different; I arrived in Kenya with no skills and a desire to assert my independence; I arrived in Shiprock with the tangible skills and personal touch of a soon-to-be primary care doctor, jumping into a new medical record system, and appointments with patients with common concerns, and early morning pre-rounding on sleeping patients who groggily answer my time-honored questions.  I am working with doctors who have preserved the old traditions of primary care—admitting and discharging their own patients from the hospital, attending intensive care rounds every morning, sharing knowledge and community with each other in this small outpost of health care, hours from any city, perched on a plain with the most dynamic sunsets I’ve seen.

My days at Shiprock have been packed with the activity of how primary care once was.  In one day, I go from ICU rounds where I’m caring for a newly diagnosed AIDS patient with pulmonary, neurologic and gastrointestinal symptoms to an early morning Tumor Board meeting where specialists from larger cities weigh in about the course of treatment for our patients.  I then start clinic, where patient panels consist of about 400 patients each and appointment lengths are flexible.  At lunch I return to the ICU to perform a lumbar puncture on my AIDS patient and then I spend the afternoon helping in walk in clinic, caring for my hospitalized patients and admitting any new patients.  The rhythm is satisfyingly diverse and challenging, allowing for the full cycle of care for patients in a way I have not yet seen.


I chose to spend a year away after college because I was afraid that in all of the specialization of my lab work and thesis and team sports and club participation, I was missing something greater about myself and my future.  I worried that the set path of graduate school would be connecting some pre-determined dots in a pattern that I didn’t like.  So I left all of the comfort of the world that I knew for a mud hut without running water or electricity.  In contrast, I am not roughing it here in Shiprock; I have the privilege of a sleek rental car and comfortable dorm room and a cafeteria with vegetarian options, but the perspective I have gained away from my current life as a fast paced resident in a fast paced program is as immeasurably beneficial.   In taking the time away to pause, I have been able to further appreciate the wealth of resources the Brigham provides, to find the words to my uncertainty, and to reflect on my values and how will they shape my future career.